Sign Up    /    Login

Jallianwala Bagh – Why Indians fired on Indians? By Rajat Mitra

This Post was shared by Dr. Unnikrishnan on a Whatsapp group

Jallianwala Bagh – Why Indians fired on Indians

I lived in Hong Kong for some years. One of the facts I observed was that Hong Kongers by and large do not like Indians and many of them even hate us. Whether an Indian goes on to look for a home or on the streets to buy groceries, the feeling is palpable. Many Indians I talked to said they feel it rather strongly. I had asked several people but got no satisfactory answer.

Finally, I asked a local friend about the reason. He was a historian at one of Hong Kong’s University. At first he tried to deny that this exists but then later said the roots of it are historical. “Do you know,” he said, “the British came to Hong Kong in 1841 and when they tried to build the first police force with the help of locals, they realized that the loyalty of the locals cannot be trusted to follow their orders or shoot and kill if their fellow brethren revolted or were a rebellion. But they realized they didn’t have the same experience in India. So they brought the Indians. The first batch of Indians who came brutalized and tortured the people here. The memory still lives in the mind of every person here and we haven’t forgiven you for it and will never do,” he said in a deeply emotional voice. “You Indians followed orders and didn’t show any mercy towards us which we expected you would do.”

I could only apologize to him and said it was an injustice. But what he had said left me perturbed. In social sciences ‘the other’ is a term that denotes how human beings divide, create walls with other groups whom they perceive as not similar to them and even inferior. For the American ‘the other’ is everyone who is outside America. For the British everyone who is not White and outside the country is ‘the other’. For the man from Pakistan it has become the Indian. Same can be said of the Chinese. But the curious thing for Indians is that for many an Indians ‘the other’ is not an outsider but another Indian only with whom his deepest chasm lies. He is someone whom we make into an enemy.

“You Indians, you have done it with your own people, like in Jallianwala Bagh. That is how the British controlled your nation for two centuries, isn’t it?” The historian’s words have stayed with me since then.

In one of his books, Amitav Ghosh, the author, writes that the British believed that the Indians can always be relied upon to ruthlessly put down any one whether their own in India or anywhere else on their orders, something they could never imagine doing with anyone else. Would a Japanese be ever trusted to fire on its own people on the orders of a foreign General? Would a Chinese army have done so when asked? I believe the answer is a big no.

As one ex-General from the former British Indian army said, “The British were masters in making the Indian people believe that they were fighting on the side of the truth and so when the Indians fought a fellow Indian they saw him as evil and felt little or no guilt killing him.”

Is that why even today we are deeply divided, can torture a fellow Indian and feel little empathy, even shoot at him or beat him to death?

Why did we Indians create ‘the other’ amongst each other and not outside like other nations do?
Once, a British historian, on the mention of Jallianwala Bagh, said that a British police force or army would never shoot at its own people if asked to do so.

Why did we Indians did it then? I believe it is worth finding an answer to this dilemma.

Why didn’t the police force refuse to follow Michael Dyer’s orders and not shoot at their own people? This maybe is one of the most poignant and perplexing questions in understanding why British could rule India.

Has the notion of ‘the other’ as one we can hate and eliminate always existed amongst us in our history and as one that the British only perfected when they came in contact with us? I wish to ask this on the 100th anniversary of the tragedy of Jallianwala Bagh if we as a society created a gap within that can cause fissures and we can again be ordered into maniacal behavior on the orders of a white man or woman.

Did we carry our philosophy of ‘vasudeva kutumbakam’ too far and become like the subjects in Milgram’s experiment?

Jallianwala Bagh to me appears to be not the action of a deranged, crazy lunatic General but of a psychopath who knew this weakness of Indians only too well, who understood this mindset in us. He knew that when ordered to fire, the men wouldn’t stop because the cries of their own country men would have no effect on them. This philosophy, sick and dangerous, may need to be addressed and understood that may lead us to kill each other or destroy. Will it ever lead us to become a united cohesive nation and not hold us back?

Creating ‘the other’ and making him into an enemy is dehumanizing which has just not only been symbolic, making us slaves but also making us lose what is the most precious, our freedom. It delineated us from the power that rightfully belonged to us as a nation.

Last year we visited the Jallianwala Bagh. There were hundreds of people laughing, talking and taking pictures. No single face looked solemn. Only some seemed curious looking at the Well or the Bullet marks on the wall. Where does this detachment from our history comes from?

Slavery dehumanized us Indians. As we know from history, no group cedes its privileges over others out of altruism but is forced to do so when the privileges they enjoy begin to threaten their survival. Gandhi could never do that to the British. Only once during the INA Trials and the Naval Revolt, it happened when the idea of one Indian being separate from ‘the other’ got erased terrifying the British into thinking it might bring their annihilation in India.

Will the present generation erase this blot? In it perhaps lies the safety that will make our future generations safe from the contradictions that pushed our ancestors into slavery and annihilating each other.

Rajat Mitra
Psychologist and Author of ‘The Infidel Next Door’

Prem Mahatani…

Yes HK locals r outright rude,to some extent u make yr own respect ,in 82 I was in chile for 1 year,beautiful country,lovely people,they use to adore indians,must hv been 25 families including Indian embassy n employees.Now there must b over 2-300 families they don’t like indians.
We try to b oversmaart n don’t follow the rules.


Best example is Bhutan. They are our protectorate. Even they they have now stopped free entry for Indians and made it 250 dollars per person. We must have displayed our smartness there.


Rules matter when it is for others, when it comes to me, what rules ? That is the attitude.
People are so obsessed with their lives that they find no hesitation in getting their work done, hook or Crook, despite knowing the fact that it badly affects the other.
Then there is one section that is always sceptic of anything reasonable. For their own gains they twist the facts to such an extent that even a believer would turn sceptic. I see so many such people on a daily basis.
Anyway the list is too long. About the committment of people here, i give this example… Give a person some money and ask him to scold someone’s father, he will do it. Give him double the amount and ask him to scold his own father, he will still do it.( Generally)


Share with:

5 2 votes
Article Rating


Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Navneet Bakshi
Navneet Bakshi
1 year ago

Yes, I agree with you. The people of HK may have their own reasons for the hate they carry in their hearts but- for all these years when they were under the British Rule, what were they doing? Disobeying laws? Rebelling against the government? Refusing to work for them? Now when they are fighting tooth and nail against the Chinese retaking control of their island, why are they resisting? Why don’t they see the Chinese as their brethren? Aren’t they their blood brothers and who are the people in the Hong Kong police? Aren’t those people who are serving in the police, using repression on the command of their bosses, who as is said are working under the orders of the powers that be on the Main Land China?

Suresh Rao
Suresh Rao
1 year ago

Those who fired on their own country men were police/army soldiers. At the time, British Law was the Law of the Land; when their commander ordered firing on the assembly of peaceful Punjabis celebrating their festival, although there were prohibitory orders on assembly of people, they had no option except to do it.

Jallianwala Baug could not happen if India, had India been independent of Britain then.

Random Posts

Placeholder Image 90 is an experiment to bring the creative people together on one platform. It is a free platform for creativity. While there are hundreds, perhaps thousands of platforms that provide space for expression around the world, the feeling of being a part of fraternity is often lacking. If you have a creative urge, then this is the right place for you. You are welcome here to be one of us.

Random Posts

Unique Remembrance

By Sabita Paintal | March 26, 2021

I was stunned to hear on phone about the sudden demise of my daughters pet dog ( mac) . He was 9 years old and of pug breed , hail and hearty, small structured and lovable. He poured too much attachment to his both doctor owners and made their lives lively . He was very…

Share with:

Read More

Visit to Vizag beach and Kailashgiri Park

By Suresh Rao | September 22, 2020 (pic-1) at link above. An  image of Vizag Beach with INS KURSURA, a submarine-museum, at left and TU aircraft museum, at right along the beach Road. Picture above is a download from facebook.    (pic-2) INS KURSURA submarine museum on beach side of R.K.Puram beach Road. It is an excellent musuem, worth visiting. I …

Share with:

Read More

Bulgakov’s Letters to Stalin

By Charumati Ramdas | October 16, 2020

The Two Letters that Made the Difference                                                                                                                                                                     -A.Charumati Ramdas   M.A. Bulgakov (1891-1940), having completed Medicine at the University of Kiev in 1916, started writing in 1919. The first short story was written in the light of a kerosene lamp in a running train and it was published in a small newspaper of a…

Share with:

Read More

Why We Should Write Daily?

By Rcay | February 13, 2022

  Why We Should Write Daily? Writing is a skill that we can develop as it is a part of communication in everyday life. We communicate with ourselves, whether we are communicating with others or making a shopping list. Writing can do wonders, as we all have something to say about something.  At the same…

Share with:

Read More

A garden that never grew.

By RAMARAO Garimella | August 12, 2020

“I’m Raju, and one day I’ll be the king.” Laxmi heard her brother as he bent his head and stepped into the hut. Sitting down, he opened the packet carefully as if it were a treasure. As she gaped at the contents, Raju declared,” here is rice and chicken curry. A special treat for my…

Share with:

Read More

वड़वानल – 35

By Charumati Ramdas | August 8, 2020

लेखक: राजगुरू द. आगरकर अनुवाद: आ. चारुमति रामदास     ‘‘हमें तुम्हारी कोरी सहानुभूति की जरूरत नहीं है,’’ गुरु ‘नर्मदा’ से मिलने आए सैनिकों से कह रहा था । ‘‘हमें ऐसी भलमनसाहत की जरूरत नहीं है कि किसी को तो हमारी कठिनाइयों   के   बारे   में,   हमारे   साथ   किये   जा   रहे   बर्ताव   के   बारे में    आवाज   …

Share with:

Read More

Wonder Woman is back in America!

By Suresh Rao | May 15, 2022

In these times of violence in movies (not to mention, gun-fights, sword fights, stone throwing, on the streets supported by political parties…) kids, teenagers (college going included,) need better entertainment on TV screens, at least during holidays. There is hardly any family entertainment lately on TV screens for us to sit in front of TV……

Share with:

Read More

Audrey Hepburn Remembered

By Suresh Rao | September 15, 2020

Audrey got her first Oscar (for best Actor, 1954) in ‘Roman Holiday’ beating Gregory Peck her co-star  in the same movie. Audrey Hepburn Life Story… ================================================================= Enjoy 1954 Movie, Roman Holiday starring Gregory Peck and Audrey Hepburn at link below: —————————————————————————————————————- Share with: 5 1 vote Article Rating

Share with:

Read More

वड़वानल – 10

By Charumati Ramdas | July 19, 2020

लेखक: राजगुरू द. आगरकर अनुवाद: आ. चारुमति रामदास     10 छत के पास अलग–अलग रंगों के तारों का जाल फैला हुआ था । उन तारों के जाल के बीच की खोखली जगह में हाथ डालकर मदन ने कुछ काग़ज निकाले और उन्हें गुरु के सामने डाल दिया । गुरु ने उन काग़जों पर नजर…

Share with:

Read More

मैं अपना प्यार – १०

By Charumati Ramdas | July 25, 2022

लेखक: धीराविट पी. नागात्थार्न अनुवाद: आ. चारुमति रामदास *Nondum amaban, et amare amabam…quaerebam quid amarem, amans amare (Latin): मैं प्‍यार करने नहीं लगा, मगर मुझे प्‍यार करने पर प्‍यार आता है, मैं इंतजार करता हूँ किसी के प्‍यार करने का, प्‍यार करने को प्‍यार करता हूँ – से० अगस्‍टीन AD (354-430) दसवाँ दिन जनवरी २०,१९८२ मैं बहुत आहत हूँ, बुरी तरह आहत हूँ। अब तक तुम्‍हारी कोई…

Share with:

Read More